This post has actually been one I have wanted to write for two years. If you are following along in the One Room Challenge, this is week 2 and usually I show off our progress during the challenge. However, I admit I haven’t gotten very far, and I don’t find it too useful to share about my hours spent looking online for perfect finds for the dining room. Instead, I want to share why I love and hate my dining room walls. The truth is that I love the look but I will never stencil a whole wall or room again. Ever. Mistakes were made and I hope that anyone attempting this can learn from my experience.
Let’s take a step back to my mindset before I ever began this project:
The first question you may wonder is why I decided to stencil the entire dining room in the first place. In my own mind, I knew I wanted some color and a subtle pattern would look beautiful against our wainscoting and crown molding. Something feminine yet fun. At first, I wanted to wall paper but I am cheapo DIY girl. My husband tells me all the time I have expensive tastes on a shoestring budget. But it all comes down to one thing…
I blame Pinterest.
The inspiration! The creativity! And every project is labeled as “easy”!
Have you seen all of the pictures of those beautifully stenciled walls on Pinterest? I had and I was hooked. I mean there were the pros:
- I have stenciled before in small scale with projects like this wall map or my favorite Beer Safe which was completed later. Clearly, I don’t mind the concept of stencils.
- Wallpaper cost – about $400. Can and a quart of paint – less than $50. Now that’s enticing!
- I was limited to any color combination I could come up with in the whole world.
Doesn’t it seem like a no-brainer?!
Oh, it was a no-brainer, but more like brain dead zombie as I trudged along during the stenciling process. So what happened?
PAINTING AND STENCILING THIS DINING ROOM TOOK 5 WEEKS AND MAYBE A 150 (OR MORE) HOURS
Yes, you read that right. Stenciling was single-handedly one of the most exhausting and tedious projects I have ever done and, truthfully, we have had our fair share of exhausting, tedious, and took-way-longer-than-we-thought projects. This one was especially grueling, however, because of it’s repetitiveness.
What went wrong?
A Flaw in Design
First, for a room this size, you still only have one stencil and you can only do one 20×24 inch area at a time. The stencil that I chose required a bit of overlap to lay straight. It was designed that way which actually seems like a good idea. However, you can’t lay a stencil down over fresh paint so we developed a system where we alternated from one side of the room to the other to stencil. When doing this on a ladder, or in corners, it made it more difficult.
1 Mistake = 100 Fixes
Second, you must understand that I am somewhat of a perfectionist when it comes to DIY. I wanted my stenciling to give crisp clean lines. You know, the ones the instructions act like it is so easy to achieve.
Here’s the thing.
Let’s say that you make 1 mistake per stencil square and some paint gets underneath the stencil or you don’t fully paint into all of the edges. Ok, now multiply just that little mistake by the 100+ times I re-positioned the stencil and that’s a ridiculous amount of mistakes.
Mistakes were harder to notice since I had chosen two colors that were very similar. In fact, when wet, the darker stencil area was almost identical to the paint color underneath.
While some may not be bothered by a a few paint blobs or light areas, I wanted professional looking results. The vast majority of time was spent with me going around with a tiny paintbrush and fixing all of the mistakes and edges. I might have honestly hand painted or fixed 20% of those walls.
Corners: the single largest reason I would never do this project again. I have seen several YouTube videos with user lining up their stencils so neatly in the corners. They just bend and tape them in there – no problem! (One of the videos was directly from the company I purchased my stencil). My stencil might as well have been like folding origami using a friend’s left hand. It was awkward, frustrating, and pretty much impossible. I basically ended up stenciling as far as I could on each side separately and then hand painting to connect it all.
Because of this, I was so convinced that my stencil was defective that I actually called the company to complain. I wasn’t necessarily looking for a refund or anything. I just wanted confirmation that I didn’t suck this bad as a DIY girl. They offered me a second stencil while assuring me that my stencil was absolutely up to their standards.
Yeah, no thanks, buddy.
Not Using the Right Tools
It has long be known to me that a stencil brush works far better than a roller. A roller is of course much faster though and I was assured that as long as I used a dense foam roller and only had a tiny bit of paint on it, everything would look designer perfect. NO way, Jose!
The end Result is that the wall is beautiful, but I would never do it again this way. I mean never. That isn’t to say that anyone should be scared of stenciling. I still love stencils for smaller projects. I just learned my lesson the hard way with this DIY stenciling project. I actually struggled with giving this post such a negative title. I do understand that some of my experience is user error. I made a lot of mistakes and I learned from them so I hope you can too. For me though, the nightmare is just still too real.
Stenciling Projects I would do again: